Leave Maes Yr Haul School Catchment Area Alone (Broadlands Residents Association)

BROADLANDS RESIDENTS ASSOCIATION
This blog is about the local council proposals to change the local school catchment area and how it impacts current and future residents of Broadlands Bridgend. The community are united in its view that NO CHANGE is REQUIRED!
http://www.broadlandsresidents.org/

21 January 2012

Minutes of the BCBC Meeting on School Catchment

Minutes from the cabinet meeting about our local school catchment change is found below. The original documentation can be found on their public website... 

A few key points have been highlighted, we are yet to see formal commitments around siblings being given equal priority to attend the same school.  Please note BCBC are looking to set a 5 year time limit on this from 2013. This means if you have a child in Maes-Yr-Haul at 2018 and have a younger child due to enter the school that year or afterwards, they will not be entitled to go to the same school.

SCHOOL CATCHMENT AREAS - BROADLANDS AND LALESTON

            The Corporate Director - Children submitted a report to update Cabinet and seek approval for consultation on changing the catchment areas of Maes yr Haul and Trelales Primary Schools with effect from September 2013.

            The report outlined background information, and advised of consultation that had previously taken place with school governing bodies, parents and communities of the above schools in 2009 and early 2011, following which three main options were considered as detailed in Paragraph 3.2 of the report.

            The report confirmed that at a meeting of Cabinet on 11 January 2011, they resolved not to consider further Option A, to further consider Option C and to carry out a consultation on the option prior to being considered further by Cabinet.

            Paragraphs 3.6 - 3.11 of the report then detailed the key issues that arose from both consultation meetings including individual responses.

            The Group Manager - Support for Children then referred Members to the main points that arose from these consultations, where there appeared to be a general consensus on certain points, namely that:

·         both schools should be in a position to meet the demand for places from within the re-configured catchment areas;

·         the new developments to the west of the estate should be allocated to Trelales Primary School;

·         a safe walking route to Trelales from Broadlands, via Gypsy Lane, should be created to allow children to travel safely to school.

            The Group Manager - Support for Children then explained that Option D had been developed in response to views expressed in previous consultations, which involved allocating further areas from Maes yr Haul to the Trelales catchment area.

            The advantages and disadvantages of the above proposals were outlined in Paragraph 5.2 of the report.

            The Group Manager - Support for Children confirmed that by allocating a longer section of the Broadlands Estate to the Trelales Primary catchment area, the Council would aim to ensure that demand for places from the catchment areas is met at both schools whilst also allowing a degree of parental preference over the choice of school.

            He added that no child would be required to move schools, whilst also the Council would aim to ensure that families who may be affected by a change to the catchment areas would be able to have all their children educated at the same school.

            Paragraph 5.5 of the report then outlined the main points that arose from further consultation in accordance with the statutory Schools Admission Code 2009.

            Paragraph 5.6 of the report then included some final points made in response to certain issues and concerns raised to be taken into consideration as they were pertinent to any final decision.

            The Group Manager - Support for Children explained that there would be some financial implications arising from the proposals to reconfigure the catchment areas of Maes yr Haul Primary and Trelales Primary schools and these were detailed in Paragraph 8.1 of the report.

            The Cabinet Member - Children and Young People explained that the proposals of the report had resulted from listening to the concerns of those involved in the consultation process and then reaching a positive conclusion on the most favourable outcome.

            RESOLVED:               That Cabinet:

                         (1)       Agreed that the proposal to allocate the areas of the Broadlands estate as set out in 5.1 and Appendix B of the report to the catchment of Trelales Primary School to become effective for admissions from September 2013 goes forward for consultation under the Schools Admissions Code 2009;
                        
                         (2)       Approved, in principle, arrangements for safe travel to Trelales Primary School from Broadlands by the construction of a footpath alongside Gypsy Lane, subject to affordability, agreements with landowners and gaining planning permission;

                                     (3)       Consult on any necessary changes to the Admissions Policy to allow, for a limited time period of 5 years initially, siblings in the two catchment areas concerned to have parity with siblings from within catchment in their entitlement to a school place of their choice.

16 December 2011

Disappointment as BCBC go ahead with changes with their eyes shut

Since 2009 we've been blogging and campaigning against BCBC Bridgend Council to leave the catchment area of Maes Yr Haul alone.

After many consultations ,  meetings with residents, meetings with the school governors, the council have decided to ignore the advice at these meetings and push forward the change in catchment.

The cost of purchasing land and the construction of a safe route to school is still unresolved and this could lead to large sums of public money being invested in yet another footpath instead of our borough school services.

Some recommendations around the sibling rule changes for admissions policies has been mentioned and we'll track that issue through the next year to ensure the council stick by their promises!

A further article can be found here: http://www.walesonline.co.uk/news/south-wales-news/bridgend-maesteg/2011/12/15/parents-left-angry-after-school-catchment-changes-91466-29954737/

Parents left angry after school catchment changes - Bridgend & Maesteg - South Wales Valleys - News from @walesonline

Parents left angry after school catchment changes - Bridgend & Maesteg - South Wales Valleys - News from @walesonline

14 December 2011

Education department present at Cabinet the Catchment Change Proposal

We just became aware of the following meeting at Cabinet

It was disappointing that no formal correspondence was provided by Bridgend County Borough Council before the meeting.

 http://www.bridgend.gov.uk/web/groups/public/documents/agenda/095816.hcsp

The report submitted is found here:
http://www.bridgend.gov.uk/web/groups/public/documents/report/095794.doc

31 October 2011

Broadlands Residents Association Press Release - Catchment Change



BROADLANDS RESIDENTS’ ASSOCIATION
Press Release

31 October 2011


Bridgend County Borough Council’s education department is consulting for a third time on proposed changes to the catchment of Maes yr Haul school in Broadlands and Trelales school in Laleston.

The change has been strongly resisted by many Broadlands residents, who see the plan as unnecessary and harmful to the community.

Residents are also angered by the way in which the Council’s officers have failed to answer key questions about their plans.

Arfon Hughes, Vice-Chair of the Broadlands Residents’ Association, commented:

“Once again the Education Department has put forward proposals to change the school catchment without providing the evidence for change that the Residents’ Association, the school governors and others have asked for.

They seem dead set on altering the catchment of Maes yr Haul school, regardless of whether it is necessary or not. Why do they continue to push this wasteful and unnecessary proposal?  

It is time for the Council to stop playing games with our community and our children’s education.  It should be spending its limited budget on teachers and equipment, not buying land from farmers to build unnecessary footpaths. “


ENDS


For further information visit our website www.broadlandsresidents.org or contact Arfon Hughes on 07590 527038

29 October 2011

Latest consultation feedback is required by 1st November 2011

The latest consultation report is still open for feedback, the local community have all received letters updating the residents on the change of catchment plans.

The council are proposing to go ahead with the catchment changes with the north west of Broadlands all being moved to Laleston / Trelales school.

The report still fails to address the purchase costs of land but  provides some benefits to parents with children already at Maes-Yr-Haul.  This isn't the best option for the community - Broadlands children should have the right to attend its local school and the council have omitted many of the facts and figures demonstrating the short term bubble considering the development is approaching an end.

We'll post up some more of those facts in case you wish to write to the council this weekend.

PLEASE respond to the consultation.

The consultation page is here: DOWNLOAD THE REPORT HERE


Please mark for the attention of Ellen Franks, or e-mail Ellen.Franks@bridgend.gov.uk
If you require the consultation document in a different format, please contact Ellen Franks on 01656 642617, email: Ellen.Franks@bridgend.gov.uk

1 October 2011

New Catchment change proposal - Option D

The school catchment changes at Broadlands Bridgend are still in a period of revision.   The options are revised once more and an Option D is being considered based on feedback from the original consultation which brings another set of streets into the discussion.

The demographics, the bubble effect of recent years and the fact that the development is at an end are still outstanding issues to be considered or addressed. 

The purchase of land around the new footpath from Broadlands to Laleston is a mute point,  although Laleston Community council has pledged £30k towards its construction, and an estimated £60k to construct it, the cost  of purchasing of land seems to be omitted from the calculations on all counts.